Pay to enter
Under OTC 1.0, a firm pays to join before it sees an award.
Consortium managers collect membership fees where the agreement allows them (DoD Inspector General, p. 3). NSTXL, a consortium manager, posts its annual dues by revenue:
| Member type | Annual revenue | Annual dues |
|---|---|---|
| Corporate | Under $10 million | $250 |
| Corporate | $10 million to $50 million | $1,000 |
| Corporate | $50 million to $100 million | $5,000 |
| Corporate | Over $100 million | $10,000 |
| University or laboratory | Any | $2,500 |
Source: NSTXL membership page, viewed Nov. 19, 2026.
A firm in more than one consortium pays each one. Dues are the small part of the bill. The larger part comes with the award.
A fee on every award
OTC 1.0 managers take a percentage of each project. The Inspector General found fees from 1.5% to 6%.
The IG sampled 13 consortium agreements. The fee sits inside the project cost, so the money comes out of the work. DoD issued no requirements or guidance on how to set these fees. One manager ran six consortia on six different fee structures (DODIG-2021-077, pp. 20-22).
| Fee terms in the IG sample | Potential fee |
|---|---|
| 1.55% on a $10 billion agreement | Up to $155 million |
| 4.3% on a $2 billion, 10-year agreement | $76 million |
| 6%, renegotiated to 2.5% as the ceiling rose to $1.4 billion | At least $35 million |
| 4.5% plus two 0.5% incentive fees, $400 million ceiling | $20.5 million |
| 5.6%, no ceiling | $2.9 million on 4 of 33 projects |
The fee layer sits on most of the money. From FY2019 through FY2021, DoD obligated more than $24 billion in prototype OTs through 28 consortia. That was nearly two-thirds of all prototype OT dollars. GAO recommended that DoD set rules for negotiating manager pay (GAO-22-105357).
The fee tracks the dollars, not the work
At 1.5% to 6%, the cut grows with every dollar of the award.
| Project value | Fee at 1.5% | Fee at 6% |
|---|---|---|
| $1 million | $15,000 | $60,000 |
| $5 million | $75,000 | $300,000 |
| $25 million | $375,000 | $1.5 million |
| $100 million | $1.5 million | $6 million |
Fee range from DODIG-2021-077, p. 22. Dollar figures are arithmetic on that range.
DoD's own guide tells agreements officers to check that fees are “commensurate with the perceived benefit to the Government” (DoD OT Guide, p. 51).
Small firms carry it
Small firms are nearly every U.S. business and most DoD vendors. Their number in the defense base fell by more than 40% in a decade.
| Measure | Figure |
|---|---|
| Small businesses in the U.S. (2022 data) | 36.2 million, 99.9% of all firms |
| Share of private-sector jobs | 45.9%, about 62.3 million workers |
| Small firms among companies doing business with DoD (FY2021) | 73% |
| Small businesses in the defense industrial base | Down more than 40% in the past decade |
| Federal prime contract dollars to small business (FY2025) | 27.58%, against a 23% goal |
Sources: SBA Office of Advocacy, Feb. 2026; DoD Small Business Strategy, Jan. 2023; CRS IN12018, June 30, 2026.
DoD's strategy names “confusing points of entry into defense markets” as a barrier. A fee at the front door and a cut on each award add to that barrier.
OTs were built to get to work
Congress built prototype OTs to reach new firms and move fast, outside the FAR.
“Encourage flexible, quicker, and cheaper project design and execution.”DoD Other Transactions Guide, July 2023, p. 5
The guide says OTs reach firms “that may not be interested in entering into” FAR contracts, and that OTs are not “FAR-based procurement contracts” (pp. 5-6).
The statute ties prototype OTs to small and nontraditional firms. Under 10 U.S.C. § 4022(d)(1), DoD may use one only if one of these holds:
- A nontraditional defense contractor or nonprofit research institution takes part to a significant extent.
- All significant participants other than the government are small businesses or nontraditional contractors.
- Sources other than the government pay at least one-third of the cost.
- The senior procurement executive finds in writing that exceptional circumstances justify the OT.
1.0 violates that spirit
The law points prototype OTs at small and nontraditional firms. OTC 1.0 charges those firms to enter and takes a share of their awards.
- No rule sets the price. DoD issued no requirements or guidance on manager fees (DODIG-2021-077, p. 22).
- DoD's guide warns that “artificially forcing performers into a particular team structure often has adverse effects on efficiency and performance.” It tells officers to ask, “What costs are associated with the consortium?” (pp. 47-48).
The hidden PM tax
A defense price tag carries program management, documentation and meetings, not only engineering.
RAND found that systems engineering and program management made up about 28% of contractor costs in guided weapons development and about 12% in aircraft development (RAND RB-190, 2006). RAND counts engineering oversight in that figure.
Cost also sets who must approve a prototype OT. Above $100 million, the head of the contracting activity signs. Above $500 million, the senior procurement executive signs, and Congress gets 30 days’ notice (10 U.S.C. § 4022(a)(2)). Every fee dollar counts toward those lines.
OTs cut through. The habits stay.
OTs cut through FAR process, but the officers who sign them learned the FAR first.
DoD's guide tells agreements officers not to “merely copy previously issued OT agreements, templates, or models.” It notes that the standard warrant form “cites the FAR as the authority for a warrant” and tells offices to edit it (DoD OT Guide, pp. 10-11).
Past performance, lost
Under OTC 1.0, the fee buys an award a little faster. The record of the firm’s work, good and bad, goes nowhere the department can use.
- The award shows. The government awards the base agreement to the manager, and each project posts as an order that names the participant (DoD OT Guide, p. 49).
- The performance does not. FAR subpart 42.15 governs past performance on contracts. OTs are not FAR contracts, and the guide sets no past performance rule for OTs.
- The data that exists is off. The IG found 13 consortium agreements listed at $24.6 billion in the federal contract database. The files showed 718 projects worth $8.7 billion (DODIG-2021-077, p. 10).
OTC 2.0
The OT is common ground for engineering. Everyone enters. In OTC 2.0, the government pays one contractor a fixed fee to keep the grounds, keep order and enforce fair play.
| OTC 1.0 | OTC 2.0 | |
|---|---|---|
| Who pays the manager | The project, through a fee inside its cost | The government, on a separate fixed-fee contract |
| Member dues | Yes, by revenue tier | None |
| Cut of each award | 1.5% to 6% | None |
| Manager’s pay grows with | Award dollars | Nothing; it is fixed |
| Performance record | None required | Kept per project, good and bad |
| Role of the manager | Toll collector | Groundskeeper |
With PM cost fixed, a program can grow without the fee growing with it. Trade-offs turn on engineering, not on fees.
The model works today. SOCOM’s SOF RACER consortium charges vendors nothing to join and nothing on their awards. The government pays the managers a firm fixed price.
“There’s no membership fee and there’s no fee on any awards they get through this consortium.” “The government pays us and our partner, GovSignals, a firm fixed price to perform.”Federal News Network, August 2026
SOCOM’s launch release calls SOF RACER “completely free for vendors” (Business Wire, Aug. 6, 2026).
What Congress can do
- Fund it. Create a designated fund for Section 873 experimentation.
- Staff it. Make consultant spend an eligible expense under Section 873.
- Name the tax. State in findings that manager fees and surcharges are a hidden tax on programs.
- Retire 1.0. Move to OTC 2.0. The government pays one contractor to keep the grounds. Members pay no fee.
- Bridge it. Pay a transition subsidy in year one. Start the fee ban in FY28.
- Explain in law. Add explanatory statement language. Issue an executive order in parallel.
Sources
- DoD Inspector General, DODIG-2021-077, Audit of Other Transactions Awarded Through Consortiums, April 2021
- GAO-22-105357, Other Transaction Agreements: DOD Can Improve Planning for Consortia Awards, Sept. 2022
- GAO-22-104621, Small Business Contracting: Actions Needed to Implement and Monitor DOD’s Small Business Strategy, Oct. 2021
- DoD Other Transactions Guide, OUSD(A&S), July 2023
- 10 U.S.C. § 4022, Authority of the Department of Defense to carry out certain prototype projects
- DoD Small Business Strategy, January 2023
- SBA Office of Advocacy, Frequently Asked Questions About Small Business, February 2026
- Congressional Research Service, IN12018, June 30, 2026
- NSTXL membership dues
- Federal News Network, Special Operations Command wants to hear from companies that have never sold it anything, August 2026
- Business Wire, USSOCOM in Partnership with GovSignals Launches SOF RACER Consortium, Aug. 6, 2026
- RAND RB-190, Systems Engineering and Program Management Costs, 2006